91
Overall
Aroma
11
Flavor
17
Mouthfeel
5
Appearance
3
Ferndale, MI
What Our Editors Thought
“Melted marshmallow on graham cracker in the aroma with subtle grilled peaches. Tighter bready caramel in the flavor with a light ethanol edge and a punchy tannic husk finish.”
What Our Panel Thought
“Dark honey and treacle as the ‘marshmallow’ character comes through, with rich vanilla. Complex and inviting cherry, strawberry, caramel, and burnt vanilla flavors. A solid bitterness backs up the alcohol; vanilla notes bring everything together.”
What the Brewers Say
“Sweet, sticky barleywine conditioned on gooey marshmallows.”
Review printed in: From Grain to Class (Spring 2026)
View All IssuesDate Reviewed: December 13, 2025