98
Overall
Aroma
12
Flavor
20
Mouthfeel
5
Appearance
3
New Ulm, MN
What Our Editors Thought
“Milk chocolate and peanut butter dominate the nose, immediately reminiscent of a Butterfinger Crisp candy bar. The body stays light and airy, with minimal bitterness and a lingering sweetness that leans playful as opposed to dessert-heavy.”
What Our Panel Thought
“Aroma is really delightful with evidence of chocolate, chopped peanuts, and some vanilla. Flavor offers more of the same, with beautiful balance from toasted-malt character. Body is on the thin side, but it feels fuller with the nut oils. Roast and chocolate-malt richness with lingering roasted nuts. Excellent balancing astringency and bitterness to the finish. Very easy to drink.”
What the Brewers Say
“Rich and creamy chocolatey flavors. Deceivingly gentle and velvety seasonal brew.”
Review printed in: From Grain to Class (Spring 2026)
View All IssuesDate Reviewed: October 31, 2025